On the Market: 10 Classic Colonial-Style Homes

By Grace Cassidy

From saltboxes and Cape Cods to Georgians and various European permutations, Colonial-style homes are instantly recognizable for their symmetrical and stately exteriors. Although the first American Colonials were built in the 1600s and 1700s, the traditional design, simple floorplans, and attractive appearance endure as one of the most popular residential architecture styles in the country. Here are 10 Colonial-style homes currently on the market in Massachusetts, New York City, Long Island, and The Hamptons.

Massachusetts

1 Marchants Path, Edgartown, Mass. | $2,849,000

This turnkey Colonial-style home sits on a half-acre parcel just moments from downtown Edgartown. The 2,254-square-foot home features three bedrooms, two-and-a-half bathrooms, a double-height living and dining area, and a gas fireplace. The kitchen features stainless-steel appliances and an island for prep space, while a mahogany-covered screened-in porch and outdoor dining area make entertaining simple. A walk-out lower level, one-car garage, and detached artist studio are also included.

New York City

40 Fifth Ave, 4D, Greenwich Village, New York City | $2,495,000

This incredible two-bedroom, two-bathroom apartment is found in a pre-war Neo-Georgian building dating back to 1929. Period details such as a wood-burning fireplace, high ceilings, moldings, and herringbone wood floors offer a peek into the time of the building’s original construction. Residents will appreciate private basement storage, a full-time doorman, an elevator operator, live-in super, and access to a beautiful private garden.

9 W 54th Street, Midtown West, New York City | $49,500,000

This breathtaking 24,000-square-foot mansion situated just off Fifth Avenue was built in the late 19th century for JP Morgan’s cousin and business partner, James J. Goodwin. The Neo-Georgian building features 11 bedroom suites plus 11 staff bedrooms, 12 fireplaces, five Juliet balconies, herringbone hardwood floors, handcrafted woodwork and millwork, stained glass, and magnificent entertaining spaces across five levels. The landmarked property can be used as a business space or investment opportunity, with proximity to New York’s best attractions such as Central Park, the MoMA, shopping, and dining.

38 W 11th Street, Greenwich Village, New York City | $11,150,000

Originally built in 1840, this brick-clad Greek Revival townhouse features iconic period details and an ideal location in the heart of Greenwich Village. The main home is complemented by a separate three-story guest house, connected via two galleries that create a secret garden in between. There are six bedrooms and six bathrooms in total, plus high ceilings, fireplaces, French doors, and a rooftop deck. The home was originally separated into four apartments, but now offers a blank canvas for future homeowners.

Long Island, NY

30 Cove Woods Road, Oyster Bay Cove, NY | $4,295,000

Built in 1960, this Oyster Bay waterfront estate known as Greenbridge was designed by Bradley Delahanty and modeled after classic English Georgian homes. Sited on over 2.5 acres of land, the peaceful retreat features original moldings, fireplaces, gardens, stone terraces, a first-floor bedroom suite, pool, and a private beach. The property also includes a brick pool house that dates back to the late 1800s.

142 Round Swamp Road, Melville, NY | $7,999,000

Situated on over two acres of land, this 8,100-square-foot Colonial-style home was once part of architect Wallace K. Harrison’s estate. Features include double iron front doors, a sprawling staircase and foyer, wood-clad library, five fireplaces, a generous kitchen plus a prep kitchen, French doors, balconies, and a primary suite with walk-in closets and an oversized spa-inspired bathroom. Outdoor living and entertaining are simplified with a generous bluestone patio, a poolside cabana, outdoor wet bar, and shaded seating.

10 Colonial Drive, Upper Brookville, NY | $6,995,000

This Georgian-style estate spans 10,000 square feet in size on five landscaped acres. Six bedrooms, six bathrooms, four fireplaces, a Baccarat chandelier in the double-height foyer, a chef’s kitchen, and library come together to create a luxurious living experience in Upper Brookville. The exterior living space is ideal for entertaining with landscaped gardens, a pool, and al fresco dining.

41 Amherst Road, Great Neck, NY | $2,795,000

Located in the Great Neck Estates, this 1927 Colonial spans 5,200 square feet with four bedrooms, four full bathrooms, and two half-baths. High ceilings, crown moldings, wainscotting, gold filigree painting, hand-painted walls, hardwood floors, and wood burning fireplaces are all included in this incredible home. The primary suite is a luxurious sanctuary complete with a fireplace, balcony, walk-in closet, and private bathroom. Residents enjoy access to Great Neck Estates amenities, including the Waterfront Park with an Olympic-sized swimming pool, kiddie pool, children’s playground, tennis courts, sports fields, docks, community events, and more.

45 Longfellow Road, Great Neck, NY | $3,795,000

This 5,200-square-foot home is sited on one-third of an acre in the Village of Saddle Rock, complete with seven bedrooms and six-and-a-half bathrooms. Features include a double-height foyer, 10-foot ceilings, a modern kitchen, generous dining room, and a den with a fireplace. The walk-out lower level offers additional living and entertaining space, complete with a bedroom, bathroom, playroom, and storage. Access to Saddle Rock Village Park means residents will enjoy a private marina, waterfront pool, tennis courts, basketball courts, and more.

The Hamptons, NY

32 Eastville Ave, Sag Harbor, NY | $2,655,250

Located on a half-acre in Sag Harbor, this 2,500-square-foot Colonial-style retreat features four bedrooms, two-and-a-half bathrooms, an open-concept kitchen, and a living room with a brick fireplace. Residents will enjoy outdoor entertaining during the warmer months by the gunite pool surrounded by a bluestone patio, kept private by hedging trees. A full basement with high ceilings offers additional living space, while a two-car garage provides great storage.