Shelter Island | Luxury Homes for Rent & Real Estate

Fireplace, Interior, Kitchen, Living room, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Kitchen, Pendant Lights, Recessed Lighting, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

Fireplace, Interior, Living room, Recessed Lighting

Interior, Living room, Recessed Lighting, Sun Room

Bedroom, Interior, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Kitchen, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Living room, Recessed Lighting

Fitness Equipment, Interior, Recessed Lighting

starting at

$40,000

/ Jun

61 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY

5 br5 ba, 1 half ba

douglas elliman exclusive

Interior, Kitchen, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Kitchen, Living room, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Living room, Wood Texture Flooring

Bedroom, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

Bathroom, Glass Shower, Interior, Recessed Lighting

Bedroom, Interior, Pendant Lights, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Kitchen, Tile Countertops, Wood Texture Flooring

starting at

$18,000

/ Jun

5 Bay Ave, Shelter Island, NY

3 br3 ba

douglas elliman exclusive

Exterior, Facade, Brick Facade, Brick Traditional

starting at

$10,000

/ Short-term

restricted address, Shelter Island, NY

4 br3 ba, 1 half ba2,774 sf

douglas elliman exclusive

Interior, Kitchen, Pendant Lights, Recessed Lighting, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

Chandelier, Dining room, Interior, Living room, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Kitchen, Living room, Pendant Lights, Recessed Lighting, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

Fireplace, Interior, Living room, Wood Texture Flooring

Bathroom, Free Standing Baths, Interior, Marble

Bathroom, Dual Sink Vanities, Free Standing Baths, Glass Shower, Interior

Bathroom, Dual Sink Vanities, Glass Shower, Interior

Exterior, Facade, Brick Facade, Cape Cod

$40,000

/ Month

xxxxxx Dickerson Dr, Shelter Island, NY

4 br3 ba, 1 half ba2,774 sf

douglas elliman exclusive

Fireplace, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Kitchen, Recessed Lighting, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

Chandelier, Dining room, Interior, Kitchen, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Bathroom, Dual Sink Vanities, Free Standing Baths, Interior, Recessed Lighting

Bathroom, Dual Sink Vanities, Glass Shower, Interior, Recessed Lighting

$35,000

/ Jul

110 South Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY

3 br3 ba

douglas elliman exclusive

Dining room, Interior, Kitchen, Pendant Lights, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Bedroom, Home Office, Interior, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Bedroom, Home Office, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Living room, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

starting at

$30,000

/ Jul

15 South Cartwright Rd, Shelter Island, NY

4 br3 ba3,100 sf

douglas elliman exclusive

Backyard, Exterior, Facade, Brick Facade, Cape Cod

Dining room, Interior, Kitchen, Pendant Lights, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

Bedroom, Fitness Equipment, Interior, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Recessed Lighting, Washer, Wood Texture Flooring

$30,000

/ Month

15 S Cartwright Rd, Shelter Island, NY

4 br4 ba3,100 sf

douglas elliman exclusive

Fireplace, Interior, Living room, Sun Room, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Living room, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Kitchen, Recessed Lighting, Stainless Steel Appliances

Fireplace, Interior, Kitchen, Pendant Lights, Recessed Lighting, Stainless Steel Appliances

Bedroom, Chandelier, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

starting at

$15,000

/ Jun

43 Lake Dr, Shelter Island, NY

4 br3 ba, 1 half ba3,046 sf

douglas elliman exclusive

Dining room, Interior, Pendant Lights, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Living room, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

$13,000

/ Short-term

80 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY

4 br2 ba1,755 sf

douglas elliman exclusive

$12,000

/ Jun

restricted address, Shelter Island, NY

5 br3 ba2,300 sf

douglas elliman exclusive

Interior, Kitchen, Stainless Steel Appliances

Interior, Kitchen, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Living room, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Bathroom, Glass Shower, Interior, Utility Closets, Washer

$12,000

/ Short-term

13 Winthrop Rd, Shelter Island, NY

2 br2 ba

douglas elliman exclusive

Interior, Living room, Pendant Lights, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Kitchen, Pendant Lights, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Kitchen, Recessed Lighting, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

Bedroom, Interior, Wooden Beams, Wood Texture Flooring

Bedroom, Interior, Wooden Beams, Wooden Ceilings, Wood Texture Flooring

Bathroom, Bedroom, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

$7,500

/ Short-term

4 Marc St, Shelter Island, NY

3 br2 ba

douglas elliman exclusive

new

Interior, Kitchen, Pendant Lights, Wood Texture Flooring

Chandelier, Dining room, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

Chandelier, Fireplace, Interior, Living room

Chandelier, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

Bedroom, Chandelier, Home Office, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

Attached, Exterior, Facade, Queen Anne Victorian

$7,000

/ Short-term

11 Prospect Ave, Shelter Island, NY

4 br2 ba, 1 half ba

douglas elliman exclusive

Dining room, Interior, Pendant Lights, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Kitchen, Marble Walls, Recessed Lighting, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Bathroom, Dual Sink Vanities, Glass Shower, Interior, Marble Walls

Exterior, Facade, Solar Panels, Farmhouse

$6,500

/ Apr

8 Burns Rd, Shelter Island, NY

3 br3 ba

douglas elliman exclusive

price reduced

Exterior, Facade, Lake, Queen Anne Victorian

Dining room, Interior, Living room, Pendant Lights, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Living room, Recessed Lighting, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Fireplace, Interior, Living room, Recessed Lighting, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Fireplace, Interior, Pendant Lights, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Fireplace, Interior, Kitchen, Pendant Lights, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Bedroom, Fireplace, Interior, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Bathroom, Dual Sink Vanities, Free Standing Baths, Interior, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Living room, Recessed Lighting, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Bedroom, Interior, Recessed Lighting, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Home Office, Interior, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Kitchen, Living room, Recessed Lighting, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

$75,000

/ Month

15 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island, NY

6 br4 ba, 1 half ba4,600 sf

Listing Courtesy of CORCORAN, MARGOT REUTTER - 631-484-0991

price reduced

Attached, Backyard, Exterior, Facade, Farmhouse

Fireplace, Interior, Living room, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Bathroom, Dual Sink Vanities, Free Standing Baths, Interior

Bathroom, Dual Sink Vanities, Interior, Marble

Chandelier, Dining room, Interior, Kitchen, Pendant Lights, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

$30,000

/ Month

104 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY

5 br5 ba, 1 half ba4,040 sf

virtual tour

Listing Courtesy of DANIEL GALE SOTHEBYS INTL RLTY, DEBRA L. VON BROOK BINDER CBR - 631-749-1155

price reduced

Dining room, Interior, Kitchen, Living room, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Kitchen, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Bathroom, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

Bathroom, Glass Shower, Interior, Washer

$14,000

/ Month

3 Lakeview Dr, Shelter Island, NY

4 br2 ba1,720 sf

Listing Courtesy of DANIEL GALE SOTHEBYS INTL RLTY, MACKENZIE NEEDHAM - 631-742-5165

FIND YOUR FAVORITE PLACE TO BE

FOR RENT

VIEW: MAP AND LIST

Luxury listings for rent in Shelter Island

FEATURED IMAGE: DEFAULT

SORT BY: DE EXCLUSIVES

61 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY

5 Bay Ave, Shelter Island, NY

restricted address, Shelter Island, NY

xxxxxx Dickerson Dr, Shelter Island, NY

110 South Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY

15 South Cartwright Rd, Shelter Island, NY

15 S Cartwright Rd, Shelter Island, NY

43 Lake Dr, Shelter Island, NY

80 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY

restricted address, Shelter Island, NY

13 Winthrop Rd, Shelter Island, NY

4 Marc St, Shelter Island, NY

11 Prospect Ave, Shelter Island, NY

8 Burns Rd, Shelter Island, NY

15 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island, NY

104 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY

3 Lakeview Dr, Shelter Island, NY